Old Mill Toronto Pastry Shoppe

Freshly made in-house

Our dedication to quality is at the heart of every pastry we create. We use only the finest, freshest ingredients, including real butter, to craft pastries that are both delicious and beautifully designed. All our pastries are made in-house right here at Old Mill Toronto Pastry Shoppe, ensuring a pure and indulgent experience. You can trust that our treats are free from additives and preservatives. For those with dietary preferences, we offer gluten-free and vegan options, so everyone can share in the joy of your special occasion.

Finest Ingredients

Ensures superior taste and quality in every bite, with ingredients carefully selected for their freshness and flavour.

No Additive or Preservatives

Guarantees a natural, pure indulgence, free from artificial ingredients that can alter the taste or quality.

Real Butter

Enhances flavour and provides a rich, authentic taste that only real butter can deliver.

Consultation with Our Pastry Chef

Work directly with our Pastry Chef to bring your vision to life and ensure your dream pastries are perfectly crafted.

Commitment to Quality

Our dedication to excellence is evident in every aspect of our production, from ingredient selection to final presentation.

Vegan & Gluten Free Options

We offer both gluten-free and vegan alternatives, ensuring that those with dietary sensitivities or preferences can enjoy our delicious pastries without compromising on taste or quality.

CUSTOM CAKES

At Old Mill Toronto Pastry Shoppe, every cake is a unique work of art, designed to reflect your personal style and make your celebration memorable. Our expert pastry chef crafts each cake from scratch using the finest, freshest ingredients, including real butter, with gluten-free and vegan options available. Whether you envision a classic design or something bold and contemporary, we’ll bring your dream cake to life. Contact us for quotes and orders, and let us make your special day even sweeter.

Cake Sizes

4", 6", 8", 10", 12"

Sponge Cake Flavours

Regular Flavours
Vanilla
Carrot
Callebut Chocolate
Red Velvet
Cinnamon

Premium Flavours
Additional Cost
Coconut
Almond
Lemon
Vegan Chocolate
Vegan Vanilla

Cake Details

Each tier of our round-shaped cakes consists of three layers of cake sponge and two layers of filling. Basic designs such as simple pipework and piped writing are included.

For three-dimensional, letter, number-shaped, or other custom cake designs beyond the traditional round shape, please contact us directly.

Cake stands, cake toppers, and any fresh flowers or greenery must be provided by the client.

Filling

Regular Filling
Vanilla - Homemade Swiss Meringue Buttercream
Chocolate - Homemade Swiss Meringue Buttercream
Strawberry - Homemade Swiss Meringue Buttercream
Cookies & Cream
Cappuccino - Homemade Swiss Meringue Buttercream
Salted Caramel - Homemade Swiss Meringue Buttercream
Cream Cheese - Buttercream
Lemon - Homemade Swiss Meringue Buttercream

Premium Filling *Additional Cost
Lemon Curd
Blackberry - Homemade Swiss
Meringue Buttercream
Vegan - Buttercream
Pastry Cream
Nutella Cream
Bailey’s - Homemade Swiss Meringue Buttercream
Mango - Homemade Swiss Meringue Buttercream
Raspberry Bavarian
Dark Chocolate Cremeux
Vegan Chocolate Ganache
Pistachio - Homemade Swiss Meringue
Buttercream

Cake Tasting & Consultation

Our Cake Tasting + Consultation package is $100 and includes a 1-hour session with our Head Pastry Chef and 6 cake tasting flavours (e.g., 1 sponge + 5 fillings or 2 sponges + 4 fillings). For a simpler option, Cake Tasting Boxes are available for pickup at $2.50 per flavour or filling, with a minimum of 4 samples.

Additional Cake Options

Layers *Additional Cost
Fresh Strawberries - Seasonal
Raspberries - Seasonal
Blueberry Compote
Sour Cherry Compote
Chocolate Chips
Crispy Chocolate Pearls
Dulce de Leche
Oreo Pieces
Chocolate Chip Cookies

Decor *Additional Cost
Ombre Effect (2 or 3 colours)
Gum Paste Decorations
Gum Paste Flowers (Individually Priced)
Vintage Piping
Rustic Textured Buttercream
Palette Knife Buttercream Florals
Edible Image Sheet (11.7" x 16.5")
Chocolate Drip (White, Milk, Dark)
Gold Drip
Gold Edge Painted
Gold Leaf Accents
Gold Splatter
Berries Decor on Top
Fondant (Tier Covered)
Macaron (Individually priced)

Sweets & Pastries

Beyond our exquisite cakes, we provide a delightful array of handcrafted treats. Our talented pastry chefs will curate a stunning assortment of desserts, tailored to your event’s theme and style, ensuring a memorable experience for you and your guests. Available for Events Hosted at Old Mill Toronto

Pastries (Sold by the Dozen, Minimum Order of 1 Dozen)

Cake Pops
Chocolate Dipped Pretzel Sticks
Chocolate Dipped Strawberries
Churros
Cinnamon Buns
Focaccia (9")
Freshly Baked Cookies
Gluten Free Mini Muffins

Hot Cross Buns
Lemon Meringue Tartlets (2")
Macarons
Mini Butter Croissants
Mini Canadian Butter Tarts
Mini Cheesecakes
Mini Cupcakes
Mini Eclairs

Mini New York Cheesecakes
Mixed Berry Tartlets (2")
Pain Au Chocolat
Regular Cupcakes
Ricotta Cannoli (3")
Scones
Sugar Cookies (3", 4", 5")
Sugar Donuts
Verrines (2")

Dessert Displays

Chocolate Fountain
Croquembouche
Macaron Tower
Sliced Seasonal Fruit & Berries

Sweet Favours

Macaron in a Gold Dome
Old Mill Honey Jar

Order

Quotes & Orders

Please contact us directly. We kindly ask that all orders be placed at least 7 days in advance to ensure availability and quality.

Contact Information For Catering:
Email: info@oldmilltoronto.com
Phone: 416-236-2641 (Press 2)

Contact Information For Dining Room:
Email: diningroom@oldmilltoronto.com
Phone: 416-207-2020

Payment Policy

Full payment is required at the time of order. Cancellations made at least 5 days before the pickup date are eligible for a full refund. Orders canceled within 5 days of the pickup date are non-refundable. We accept all major payment methods, including online and contactless payments. Please note, however, that American Express is not accepted.

Allergy Statement

Our menu may contain or come into contact with wheat/gluten, milk, eggs, peanuts, tree nuts, fish, shellfish, and soy. Old Mill Toronto Hospitality Inc. is not a nut-free facility. While we aim to accommodate mild food allergies and dietary restrictions, we cannot guarantee that all requests can be fully met as there are no guaranteed precautions we can take to ensure zero cross contamination for severe allergies.

Cake Consultation & Tasting

Our Cake Tasting + Consultation Package is $100 and includes a 1-hour consultation with our Head Pastry Chef and 6 cake tasting flavours. Alternatively, we offer a Cake Tasting Box available for pickup, priced at $2.50 per sponge flavour and $2.50 per filling, with a minimum of 4 samples. Contact us to schedule your tasting.

Read Our

Testimonials

Everyone Loved the Strawberry Shortcake!!

We would like to take this time to thank you for making our wedding an amazing experience for us, we would like to Thank Wilma our room captain and the servers for the great service we receive, everyone is talking about how great the food was and especially the Strawberry Shortcake. Robert our bartender is still receiving praise from our guests for his talents and the drinks he was serving up.

Beautiful Cake and Delicious Pastries!

We enjoyed a fabulous dinner and belated wedding reception party with our family and friends – so many compliments! From Alaine at reception to Alex, Wilma and Wanda in the hall, everything was so smooth and easy on event day. Also, kudos to Luciana’s beautiful cake and delicious pastries! Just beautiful. Thank you!

Absolutely Loved Our Wedding Cake

Thank you Luciana and the team so very much for everything on Saturday. Luciana has been such a pleasure meeting and working with and we absolutely loved our wedding cake. Not only was it delicious, but it was everything we could have asked for aesthetically. The addition of the fresh flowers, our cake topper and Harry (nose-diving into the back of the cake!), was everything we had envisioned.

We couldn’t have asked for a more perfect and beautiful day Saturday, and Luciana was a huge part of that equation. She helped to make this process a seamless and thoroughly enjoyable one for us and for that we are truly grateful.

We would recommend you and the entire team at the Old Mill without hesitation and in the highest regard. Thank you again for everything.

Delicious!

Thank you! The cake was not only lovely, but delicious. Maria loved it!

Lovely Bridal Shower Cake

I wanted to thank you for creating/baking such a lovely cake for our bride-to-be Amanda. Everyone raved about it. It was beautiful to look at and so delicious—both flavours.

Gorgeous Cake!!

The cake was gorgeous ! Thank you Sarah ! The pastry team is doing a great job – thank you Luciana / Sarah, and the rest of the team…

Stunning Cake and Unforgettable Memories – Thank You!

I personally wanted to thank you for the most gorgeous cake yesterday. It was exactly what I wanted and more. Thank you for bringing my vision to life and making my daughter’s day memorable. Everyone was in awe of it and it tasted great as well.